• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to secondary sidebar
  • Home
  • News
    • 2A
    • Industry
    • Political
    • Press Releases
    • Self Defense
  • Reviews
    • Ammo
    • Gear
    • NFA
    • Optics
    • Pistols
    • Rifles
    • Shotguns
  • Authors
  • About Us
  • Submit a Post
  • Contact Us
  • Login/Register
  • Advertise With Us

The Gun Point

Promoting the 2nd Amendment using the 1st Amendment

  • Subscribe to The Gun Point Newsletter
  • Get Social with TGP

“Stand Your Ground” Laws Are Not A Defense

May 21, 2019 by John Delmonico 1 Comment

Perhaps the most widely misunderstood, misquoted, and misapplied doctrine within self-defense law is that of the “Stand Your Ground” statute. This is largely caused by the massive amount of biased, slanted, and out right lies told to us by anti-gun politicians, agenda driven prosecutors, and their accomplices within the mainstream media.

A significant amount of people, as well as the afore-mentioned politicians, prosecutors, and so-called reporters believe that it is a way of claiming self-defense and/or of legally committing murder under the guise of self-defense. Either way, both are wrong.

The concept of “Stand Your Ground” is simple to understand and apply. The ONLY thing that a “Stand Your Ground” statue does is remove your duty to retreat if you are legally allowed to be at the location.

It removes the self-defense element of avoidance. “That is, the legal duty of the defender to retreat from the attacker, before the defender may lawfully use defensive force, if a safe avenue of retreat is available. This is what “Stand-Your-Ground” does, and this is all it does: it waives the otherwise existing legal duty of a defender to retreat before using defensive force.” Attorney Andrew Branca.

“Stand Your Ground” does not eliminate the other four elements required for a claim of self-defense. Imminence, innocence, proportionality, and reasonableness are all still required for a successful claim of self-defense. If a prosecutor can convince a jury or judge that one or more of these elements were not met your claim of self-defense is gone regardless of your right to “Stand Your Ground”.

Another thing to remember is that most states are not “Hard Stand Your Ground” states. Meaning that the prosecutor is not even allowed to mention that you could safely retreat. Most are “Soft Stand Your Ground” states, which means that the prosecutor can still argue that while you did not have a specific duty to retreat, a reasonable person who was in the same set of circumstances would have retreated to safety before using whatever force was necessary to defend themselves. Do you want that argument made to a jury?Are you willing to trust your life to their judgement?

Having said that, it is my opinion that regardless of a “Stand Your Ground” statue, if you have a safe means of retreat you should take it. Once you decide to engage in a defensive use of force, deadly or non-deadly, your risk of being injured or killed and your risk of going to jail dramatically increases. The best fight to be in is always the one that did not happen.

Remember, it is your job to know that law and how it applies to your given set of circumstances. Trying to figure it out while you are in the conflict is too late. Find a reputable source within your state who is qualified to teach the legal aspects of self-defense and educate yourself before the fight. An excellent resource is the book “The Law of Self Defense, 3rd Edition” by Attorney Andrew Branca. He literally wrote the book on the laws surrounding self-defense and it covers all 50 states. I do not have any financial or other relationship with Attorney Branca, it is my opinion that he is one of the best resources regarding self-defense law out there today.

I understand that the legal matters that revolve around self-defense are a complex topic with many other factors involved. I hope that future articles will help to shed some light on this multifaceted issue. Nothing in this article should be considered legal advice and the content is solely for educational and discussion purposes.

John
Delmonico

Owner of
Active Response Training and Consulting, LLC

www.artcmt.com

Law Of Self
Defense Instructor Program Graduate

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Filed Under: News, Self Defense Tagged With: 2nd amendment rights, 2ndamendment

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualified purchases.

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Jay Walsh says

    May 22, 2019 at 8:15 am

    Well stated. It’s a nice reminder to stay up on the current requirement of the law. One simple mistake can lead to a healthy amount of Lawyer expense. Thank You Mr Delmonico for your contribution to my daily reading material!

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Stay Updated

Get Social With Us

Follow us on Instagram
Check us out on Facebook
Check us out on Facebook
fb-share-icon
Visit us on Twitter
Follow Me
Subscribe

Recent Posts

  • Galco’s DAO Strong Side or Crossdraw Holster January 8, 2021
  • Primary Arms Optics GLx 2x Prism Wins ‘Best CQB Optic’ Award January 8, 2021
  • Riton Optics Products Available on Strelok Pro Ballistic Calculator January 7, 2021
  • N8 Tactical Pro-Lock Holster January 6, 2021
  • Heritage Introduces the Barkeep™ Revolver January 6, 2021